Ethos Education

Doctor Who: The Rebel Flesh: What is a soul and does it exist?

Leave a comment

Learning Objectives:

  • Understanding Christian beliefs about the soul and the body.

Learning Outcomes:

  • Students will reflect upon what defines their sense of self.
  • Reflect upon the possible existence, purpose and significance of the human soul.
  • Evaluate the following points of view – materialism, idealism and the biblical Christian explanation of the link between soul and body – as they relate to the issue of human consciousness.
  • Synthesise learning by writing a company report on the Ganger incident from Doctor Who, expressing different perceptions of soul and consciousness as they relate to that scenario.

STARTER:

Ask the students to write down three things about themselves (you might want to warn them that they may have to reveal what they have written down to others, so this isn’t the place for revealing their deepest, darkest secrets).

Ask the students to write down three things about themselves that they feel help to define who they are. They could be to do with where they were born or grew up, with their family circumstances, with the things they like doing or the things that they are good at doing, or anything else that the student feels is important. You might want to warn them that they may have to reveal what they write down to others before they start writing down their deepest, most embarrassing secrets.

Ask one or two students to share what they have written with the rest of the class. Ask if the revealed facts make that person unique? If those are the things that define who you are, what would it mean if someone else was also able to make exactly the same claims? What else makes a person uniquely themselves? Students may bring up biological issues such as DNA. Ask them what that says about twins, particularly identical twins. What defines twins as people, particularly what defines them as unique and distinct from their twin?

Explain that in today’s lesson you are going to be thinking about the idea of the soul, a key concept in the Christian faith.

MAIN ACTIVITIES:

Introduce the first clip from the Doctor Who episode The Rebel Flesh. This is available on the DVD Doctor Who: Series 6 part 1b (BBC DVD, 2011, certificate 12). Click here to buy a copy of the DVD online.

Explain to the students the Doctor (Matt Smith), Amy (Karen Gillan) and Rory (Arthur Darvill) have landed at an old monastery that is now being used to produce industrial acid. The Doctor is just about to discover the unusual methods that the workers have for keeping themselves safe from the dangerous material they have to work with. Ask the students to pay particular attention to what Cleaves (Raquel Cassidy), the workers’ leader, says about ‘the Flesh’.

  • Start time:       0.08.35 (in chapter 4 of the DVD)
  • End time:        0.13.10
  • Clip length:     4 minutes and 35 seconds

The clip starts with a shot of the vat. The Doctor and the others walk into the room and the Doctor closely inspects the contents of the vat. The first line is the Doctor saying, ‘And there you are’. The clip ends after Buzzer (Marshall Lancaster) says, ‘No need to get poncy – it’s just gunge.’ If you want a shorter clip, stop at 0.11.38, after Cleaves says, ‘Now, why don’t you stand back and let us impress you?’ This will mean missing out on the demonstration of Jen (Sarah Smart).

Remind the students of Cleaves’ statement about putting her consciousness into a Ganger – ‘It’s just like operating a fork-lift truck’ – and the Doctor’s warning that the flesh is ‘so alive, and you’re plugging your lives, your personalities directly into it’. What do students think about the idea of an artificial body that is simply a vehicle for an outside consciousness to control? If such a thing were possible in the real world, would they see the artificial body as being just a vehicle – like a fork-lift truck – as Cleaves says, or something more, as the Doctor suggests?

Introduce a second clip from the episode. Since the previous clip, a huge electrical storm has caused problems at the factory. Ask the students to think how they would feel if they were faced with the predicament that becomes apparent for the factory workers during the clip.

  • Start time: 0.16.05 (in chapter 6 of the DVD)
  • End time: 0.20.24
  • Clip length: 4 minutes and 19 seconds

The clip starts with first the Doctor, then other characters waking up. The first line is Rory saying, ‘For want of a better word, Ow.’ The clip ends with the Doctor describing the situation faced by the gangers: ‘Scared, disorientated, struggling to come to terms with an entire life in their heads.’

Explain, in case anyone hasn’t followed the clip, that the electrical storm has caused the Gangers to remain alive even when the original worker is no longer plugged into the harness. They seem to be struggling with the idea that an alternative version of them, with all of their memories and personality traits, is now independently walking around the factory.

Ask the students whether the Ganger is equally alive as the human on whom it was based. How would the students feel if they discovered there was an alternative version of them created in this fashion? Would the Ganger version of them have an equal claim to be them? Would the Ganger, having come to independent life, have a soul? Allow some time for students to discuss what they think a soul is, and whether they think that such a thing exists at all.

Explain that for the remainder of the lesson, you are going to look at three contrasting points of view concerning the human soul and consciousness. The modern scientific materialist view, as advanced by Francis Crick, concentrates on the processes of the body and denies the soul. The philosophical view of Descartes concentrates on the human thought process and denies the body. Finally, the Christian view unites body and soul, with an emphasis on their interdependence.

According to materialism, the human being is a machine that has no user, and our feelings of being a unique individual are false; we are simply at the mercy of our bodily and mental functions. This perspective is sometimes described as ‘nothing buttery’, not because of any aversion to dairy spreads, but because it says the mind is nothing but the physical component parts.

Read the following quote from one of the discoverers of DNA, Francis Crick:

‘Your joys, your sorrows, your memories and your ambitions, your sense of personal identity and free will are no more than the behaviour of a vast assembly of nerve cells and their assorted molecules. As Lewis Carroll’s Alice might have phrased it: ‘You’re nothing but a pack of neurons.’ (Taken from Crick’s The Astonishing Hypothesis)

Ask the class to discuss in groups how they feel about this theory.

  • Do they accept the idea that they are nothing more than a machine?
  • How would they explain their thoughts and emotions?
  • How could they use this theory to explain why they didn’t do last week’s homework?

Introduce the second theory on the nature of being: idealism.

Ask the pupils if anyone has heard the phrase ‘Cogito ergo sum’ (‘I think therefore I am’). Do they know what it means? Explain that it was coined by the philosopher Descartes. He doubted the existence of the outside world, but he could not refute his own doubting and therefore deduced he must exist to be thinking these thoughts. For Descartes the world of thoughts and reflection was more important than the material world. For example, Descartes did not believe animals could feel pain as they had no rational thought – he would have made an unlikely advocate for animal rights!

Descartes’ theory – idealism – is opposed to the materialism of Crick. For him the human spirit, particularly reason, is our reality. To claim that we are nothing but machines is a denial of the human experience we share.

Ask the class how they respond to Descartes’ ideas. Which theory do they prefer – materialism or idealism? What shortcomings can they see with either theory?

The third view point is the biblical, Christian perspective. The Bible provides a view of a person as being both body and soul. This is not to say that there are two versions of people. Rather, Christians believe they have a body but that they are the soul. A complete person is an embodied soul – and in heaven Christians believe they will still be embodied souls, although the nature of the heavenly bodies will not necessarily be the same as earthly bodies.

Divide the class into pairs and ask them to look up the following Bible references. What evidence is there in these verses for the Christian view of the importance of both body and soul?

Love the Lord your God with all your heart and with all your soul and with all your strength.

(Deuteronomy 6:5, NIV)

Do you not know that your body is a temple of the Holy Spirit, who is in you, whom you have received from God? You are not your own; you were bought at a price. Therefore honour God with your body.

(1 Corinthians 6:19-20, NIV)

Do not be afraid of those who kill the body but cannot kill the soul. Rather, be afraid of the One who can destroy both soul and body in hell.

(Matthew 10:28, NIV)

I urge you, brothers, in view of God’s mercy, to offer your bodies as living sacrifices, holy and pleasing to God – this is your spiritual act of worship.

(Romans 12:1, NIV)

But our citizenship is in heaven. And we eagerly await a saviour from there, the Lord Jesus Christ, who, by the power that enables him to bring everything under his control, will transform our lowly bodies so that they will be like his glorious body.

(Philippians 3:20-21, NIV)

So will it be with the resurrection of the dead. The body that is sown is perishable, it is raised imperishable; it is sown in dishonour, it is raised in glory; it is sown in weakness, it is raised in power; it is sown a natural body, it is raised a spiritual body.

(1 Corinthians 15:42-44, NIV)

Allow 5-10 minutes for this activity, then ask for feedback. Throughout the Bible reference is made to body and soul – both are described as being part of God’s design for humanity, for this life and for eternity.

SUMMARY AND ASSESSMENT OF LEARNING:

As a final exercise, ask the students to write a report of the events shown in the Doctor Who clip. The report should focus on the new discoveries about the Gangers, and make recommendations for what the company should do next based upon the report-writer’s own belief about the soul. The report-writer does not have to put forward the student’s own views, and the report should also acknowledge the dissenting opinions of other members of the report committee (representing the other two views examined in sections 4 to 6).

YOU WILL NEED:

Leave a Comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s